Modesty for Men in Islamic Teaching

Modesty is often discussed as though it were a subject concerning women alone. The primary sources do not present it that way. The Qur’anic passage most frequently cited on modest dress addresses men first and women immediately afterwards, and the hadith literature contains a substantial body of material on male dress, bearing and conduct. This article sets out what those sources say, with references, and points towards where more detailed guidance can be found.

The Order of the Verses

In Surah an-Nur, the instruction on modesty begins with men. Verse 30 (an-Nur 24/30) directs believing men to restrain their gaze and to guard their chastity, noting that this is better for them. Verse 31 (an-Nur 24/31) then addresses believing women with a parallel instruction, adding the specific guidance on covering.

Commentators frequently draw attention to this sequence. The command concerning the gaze and personal chastity is given to men before it is given to women, which indicates that the subject is a shared obligation rather than one assigned to a single group. Reading verse 31 without verse 30 produces an incomplete picture of what the passage requires.

Modesty as a Shared Quality

Surah al-Ahzab reinforces this. Verse 35 (al-Ahzab 33/35) lists the qualities of the righteous in matched pairs — believing men and believing women, truthful men and truthful women, patient men and patient women — and includes among them those who guard their chastity, again naming both. The verse is a clear statement that the moral qualities it describes, modesty among them, are expected of both.

The hadith literature treats modesty in the same way. Narrations recorded in both Bukhari and Muslim, in their chapters on faith, describe modesty or haya as a branch of faith. The wording is general and is not addressed to one group.

What the Sources Say About Men’s Dress

On the question of covering, the hadith collections contain narrations indicating that the area between the navel and the knee is to be covered for men. Material of this kind appears in the collections of Abu Dawud and Tirmidhi, and jurists discuss the strength of the individual reports and the resulting obligation at some length. Where I am not certain of a specific report number I have named only the collection, and anyone wanting to examine the chains and gradings should consult a scholarly edition.

Beyond the minimum, the sources address the manner of dress rather than only its extent. Narrations in Bukhari and Muslim record disapproval of clothing worn out of arrogance or for display, including the practice of letting garments trail along the ground in a show of status. The concern in these reports is the attitude the clothing expresses, not the fabric itself.

There are also well-known narrations, found in the major collections, prohibiting men from wearing silk and gold ornamentation, and prohibiting either sex from imitating the dress of the other. The scope of these rulings and their application to modern garments is discussed differently by different schools, which is why a reliable scholarly source matters here more than a summary.

Modesty of Conduct and Bearing

The Qur’an connects modesty to the way a person carries themselves. Surah al-Furqan describes the servants of the Most Merciful as those who walk upon the earth in humility (al-Furqan 25/63). Surah Luqman instructs against walking with arrogance and against raising the voice unnecessarily (Luqman 31/18-19). Neither passage mentions clothing, and both are addressed generally.

This widens the subject considerably. Modesty in these verses covers speech, manner, how one occupies space and how one treats others. A person can meet every requirement of dress and fail the standard these verses set, which is why classical treatments of haya place it among the qualities of character rather than among the rules of appearance.

Guarding the Gaze

The instruction in an-Nur 24/30 on restraining the gaze is worth noting on its own, because it is the part of the passage most often passed over. The verse makes it a direct responsibility of men, stated before any instruction given to women. Scholars discussing this verse commonly observe that it places the burden on the one who looks, and that a framework which assigns responsibility only to the one who is seen does not reflect the text.

The hadith collections contain material on the same theme, including narrations on turning the gaze away rather than letting it linger. These reports appear in the main collections, and again the details of grading are matters for a scholarly source.

Why the Imbalance in Discussion

If the sources address both, it is reasonable to ask why the public conversation has narrowed. Part of the answer is that the guidance for women includes more specific detail about dress, which generates more discussion of detail. Part of it is cultural, in that scrutiny of appearance has historically fallen more heavily on women in many societies, inside and outside Muslim communities.

Whatever the cause, the effect is that a shared obligation is often presented as a one-sided one. Returning to the order and wording of the verses is a straightforward corrective.

Where to Look Further

This article is a summary of what the primary sources contain and does not issue rulings. The specific obligations of dress for men, the status of individual narrations and the differences between the schools of law are all matters where a qualified source is necessary. For detailed and reliable guidance, readers in Turkey can consult the publications and enquiry services of the Presidency of Religious Affairs, Diyanet İşleri Başkanlığı, and elsewhere a recognised scholarly authority.

Conclusion

The Qur’an addresses modesty to men in an-Nur 24/30 before addressing women in 24/31, and al-Ahzab 33/35 lists it among qualities expected of both. The hadith collections treat haya as a branch of faith, set a standard for men’s covering, and criticise dress worn for display. Taken together, the sources describe modesty as a quality of character expressed in dress, gaze and bearing — and as an obligation that was never addressed to one group alone.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir